The Ketogenic Diet: Weighing The Benefits Against The Criticisms

The Ketogenic Diet: Weighing The Benefits Against The Criticisms


August 12, 2025 | Jane O'Shea

The Ketogenic Diet: Weighing The Benefits Against The Criticisms


The ketogenic diet, or “keto,” has turned into a mainstream wellness trend in recent years. By slashing carbohydrate intake and upping fat content, the body goes into a state called ketosis: the burning of fat for fuel. Many have sung the praises of keto’s benefits for weight loss, others have criticized its sustainability and possible health risks. Let’s take a clsoer look at keto and who can get the most of this diet.

How Keto Works

On keto, carbs are held back to roughly 20–50 grams per day. This drives the body to depend on stored fat for energy. This metabolic change produces ketones, which are now used as fuel instead of glucose. This usually results in a drop in blood sugar and insulin levels, which may bring further benefits for those with certain health conditions.

poached egg with vegetables and tomatoes on blue plateBrooke Lark, Unsplash

Advertisement

Potential Upside Of Keto

Supporters emphasize rapid weight loss, better blood sugar control, less hunger pangs, and sharper mental focus as the big upsides. Some studies indicate keto may benefit those with type 2 diabetes, epilepsy, or metabolic syndrome. Also, many people report reduced cravings for sugary snacks and feeling more full from high-fat meals. This makes it easier to stay on track with their diet.

The Naysayers Weigh In

Critics point out the diet’s strict nature and possible long-term consequences. Very low carb intake can cause nutrient deficiencies if not done carefully. Some people suffer from “keto flu”: bouts of fatigue, headaches, and irritability as the body adjusts. There are also worries that high saturated fat intake can be bad for the heart in some people.

flat lay photography of raw salmon fishDavid B Townsend, Unsplash

Advertisement

Who Stands To Gain

People with insulin resistance, prediabetes, or type 2 diabetes could find keto useful at improving glucose control. People with epilepsy, especially drug-resistant cases, can also benefit, as keto has already been in use for decades in this context. People looking to lose fat while feeling less hungry may also find keto beneficial, as long as they can stick to the diet’s restrictions.

Those Who Should Be Cautious

Keto isn’t for everyone. People with liver or pancreatic conditions, gallbladder disease, or a history of disordered eating should avoid keto or only do it under a doctor’s guidance. Endurance athletes might have a hard time on strict keto because of the body’s need for glycogen during longer sessions of high-intensity activity. Pregnant or breastfeeding women are also not recommended to go keto.

Mikhail NilovMikhail Nilov, Pexels

Advertisement

The Challenge Of Lifestyle And Sustainability

One of the biggest stumbling blocks of keto is just sticking with it long term. Social eating, cultural food traditions, and personal taste can make strict carb restriction hard to sustain. Some people try a “cyclical keto” system, switching back and forth between low-carb and higher-carb days to give themselves a break while still getting some benefits.

Food Quality

A healthy ketogenic diet is partly about cutting carbs, but also about eating nutrient-dense foods. Avocados, olive oil, nuts, fatty fish, leafy greens, and non-starchy vegetables can provide essential vitamins and minerals. Eating too much processed meat, cheese, and butter can give you short-term results but could be a long-term detriment to your health.

woman standing in front of fruits holding pot's lidJason Briscoe, Unsplash

Advertisement

The Bottom Line

The ketogenic diet can be a great tool to lose weight and improve your metabolism if you do it carefully. But as we've seen, it requires careful planning, medical guidance for some of us, and honesty about whether it fits your lifestyle. For those willing to try it, keto can be transformative, but it’s certainly not for everybody.

You May Also Like:

The Microbiome Is Reshaping What We Thought We Knew About Diet

The Science Behind New Routines—and How to Start

The Evolution of Beauty Standards Throughout The Years

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4


READ MORE

Morning Person Vs Night Owl: Which One Is Better For You?

People have argued for centuries about whether early risers or night owls are more productive. Science suggests that each lifestyle has its benefits.
August 15, 2025 Sasha Wren

A Regular Dose Of Boredom Is Good For Your Mental Well-Being

In today’s culture, boredom is viewed as a problem to be solved instantly, but a minimum level of boredom is actually necessary for our own mental well-being.
August 14, 2025 J.D. Blackwell

Ozempic For Weight Loss: Is It Worth It For Non-Diabetics?

Ozempic has gained a reputation as a “miracle” weight loss drug, but just because you can take it doesn’t necessarily mean you should.
August 13, 2025 Quinn Mercer

The Ketogenic Diet: Weighing The Benefits Against The Criticisms

The ketogenic diet is popular for its potential to help people lose weight, but many still criticize its sustainability and possible health risks. We weigh the positives and the negatives.
August 12, 2025 Jane O'Shea

Walking Is The Unsung Hero Of Personal Fitness

Research shows that walking offers great health benefits with no training or equipment needed.
August 11, 2025 Marlon Wright

The Microbiome Is Reshaping What We Thought We Knew About Diet

A growing body of research shows that the key to better health is not in how much you eat, but in what you feed your gut bacteria.
August 8, 2025 Peter Kinney